Gifts Under $2500

Fine Jewelry & Gifts Under $2,500

For the moments that call for something truly significant, this is where to start. At Croghan's Jewel Box, our Gifts Under $2,500 collection brings together exceptional fine jewelry and gifts that speak to the weight of the occasion — pieces with genuine craftsmanship, rare beauty, and the kind of lasting value that only comes from buying well.

Whether you're celebrating a milestone anniversary, a major achievement, or someone who deserves the very best, you'll find something here that rises to the moment. From stunning diamond pieces and fine colored gemstones to heirloom-quality estate finds, each piece in this collection is chosen to make a real impression.

Shop online or visit us in Charleston — we're honored to help you find something this special.

298 products
Sort by
Sort by
Victorian 18K yellow gold ring with three rubies alternating with two diamonds and engraved scroll details. Angled view of Victorian ruby and diamond 18K yellow gold ring showing the wide band and engraved scroll detail.
Victorian Ruby & Diamond Five-Stone 18K Yellow Gold Ring
$ 1,675.00
Tippy Stern Rainbow Row necklace with green, light blue, and pink gemstone beads, an ornate yellow gold rondelle, and a canoe charm. Model wearing a Tippy Stern Rainbow Row beaded necklace with green beads at the front, light blue and pink beads along the sides, and a yellow gold rondelle.
Tippy Stern Rondelle & Multi-Stone Rainbow Row Beaded Necklace 16"
$ 2,000.00
Tippy Stern faceted black tourmaline beaded necklace with a diamond pavé yellow gold rondelle and canoe charm. Model wearing a Tippy Stern turquoise and hessonite garnet necklace with yellow gold rondelles, layered with a Tippy Stern black tourmaline necklace with a diamond pavé rondelle.
Tippy Stern Diamond Rondelle & Black Tourmaline Beaded Necklace 16.5"
$ 2,400.00
Tippy Stern turquoise and faceted hessonite garnet beaded necklace with two ornate yellow gold rondelles and a canoe charm. Model wearing a Tippy Stern turquoise and hessonite garnet necklace with yellow gold rondelles, layered with a Tippy Stern black tourmaline necklace with a diamond pavé rondelle.
Tippy Stern 2-Station Rondelle, Garnet & Turquoise Beaded Necklace 16.5"
$ 2,220.00
Tippy Stern aquamarine beaded necklace with a yellow gold Greek key rondelle, spacer beads, and canoe charm. Model wearing a Tippy Stern hessonite garnet necklace with yellow gold rondelles, layered with a blue aquamarine beaded necklace.
Tippy Stern Rondelle & 4.5mm Aquamarine Beaded Necklace 16.5"
$ 1,820.00
Emerald-Cut Blue Topaz & Diamond 18K White Gold Necklace
Emerald-Cut Blue Topaz & Diamond 18K White Gold Necklace
$ 1,961.25 $ 2,615.00
14K yellow gold paperclip link bracelet arranged in a circle with its toggle clasp open. 14K yellow gold paperclip link bracelet worn on the wrist, showing its polished elongated links.
14K Yellow Gold Italian Toggle Clasp Link Bracelet 7.5"
$ 1,960.00
Pair of 14K yellow gold snake huggie earrings with pavé diamond heads, emerald eyes, and engraved scale details. Model wearing a 14K yellow gold diamond and emerald snake huggie earring, showing its fit around the earlobe.
Diamond & Emerald Pavé 14K Gold Snake Huggie Earrings
$ 2,175.00
Pair of 14K yellow gold starburst stud earrings with diamond cluster centers and alternating rope-textured and pavé diamond rays. Front and side views of 14K yellow gold diamond starburst stud earrings, showing the openwork design and post.
Diamond Cluster Pavé 14K Gold Starburst Stud Earrings
$ 2,210.00
14K yellow gold triple rolling ring with three interlocked polished bands crossing over one another. 14K yellow gold triple rolling ring worn on a hand, showing its interlocking bands and scale.
14K Yellow Gold Triple Rolling Band
$ 2,025.00
Sloane Street Sterling Silver Mix Shape Blue Topaz Bangle with 18K Gold Bezels Sloane Street Sterling Silver Mix Shape Blue Topaz Bangle with 18K Gold Bezels
Sloane Street Sterling Silver Mix Shape Blue Topaz Bangle with 18K Gold Bezels 6.5"
$ 1,950.00
Round citrine pendant with a trio of diamonds and twisted rope accents in 14K yellow gold on a cable chain, shown on a white background. Citrine and diamond pendant necklace in 14K yellow gold worn below the collarbone, showing its round golden-orange gemstone and delicate cable chain.
Citrine & Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Pendant Necklace
$ 2,100.00
14K yellow gold flexible bangle with five alternating pink sapphire and diamond rondelle stations, shown on a white background. Pink sapphire and diamond rondelle bangle in 14K yellow gold worn on the wrist beside a diamond rondelle bangle.
Pink Sapphire & Diamond 5-Station Rondelle 14K Yellow Gold Flexible Bangle
$ 2,235.00
East-west emerald-cut diamond solitaire ring with a bezel setting and ribbed 14K yellow gold band. Side view of emerald-cut diamond solitaire ring showing the bezel setting and ribbed 14K yellow gold band.
.50ct Emerald-Cut Diamond Solitaire Bezel Set 14K Gold Ribbed Ring
$ 2,175.00
Round diamond solitaire ring with a bezel setting and ribbed 14K yellow gold band. Side view of round diamond solitaire ring showing the bezel setting and ribbed 14K yellow gold band.
.50ct Round Diamond Solitaire Bezel Set 14K Gold Ribbed Ring
$ 1,625.00
Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Beaded 5 Row Ring Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Beaded 5 Row Ring
Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Beaded 5-Row Ring
$ 2,450.00
Oval Sapphire & Round Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Band Oval Sapphire & Round Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Band
Oval Sapphire & Round Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Band
$ 1,625.00
Jade Trau Posey II Stud Earrings Jade Trau Posey II Stud Earrings
Jade Trau Posey II Stud Earrings
$ 2,450.00
Diamond Triple Bezel Milgrain 3-Station 14K White Gold Flex Bangle
Diamond Triple Bezel Milgrain 3-Station 14K White Gold Flex Bangle
$ 1,985.00
Diamond Pavé 14K Yellow Gold Ribbed Ring Diamond Pavé 14K Yellow Gold Ribbed Ring
Diamond Pavé 14K Yellow Gold Ribbed Ring
$ 2,235.00 $ 2,980.00

Exquisite pieces for every occasion

Shop by Price

Under $250

Shop

Under $500

Shop

Under $1500

Shop

Under $2500

Shop

Under $5000

Shop